One Night in Vermont: The Vanishing of Brianna Maitland
The Disappearance of Brianna Maitland
Published by Crime Clueless Podcast
The car was still running.
The lights were on.
Her uncashed paycheck was in the passenger seat.
And the whole thing?
Was backed into an abandoned barn like a scene from a horror movie.
But this wasn’t fiction. This was Brianna Maitland’s last known moment—and almost 20 years later, no one has been able to explain it.
The Vanishing
On March 19, 2004, 17-year-old Brianna finished her shift at the Black Lantern Inn in Montgomery, Vermont. She told coworkers she was heading to a friend’s house for the night—but she never made it. The next day, her green 1985 Oldsmobile was found in a bizarre position: backed halfway into a run-down barn along Route 118, with a broken headlight and signs of… well, we don’t really know what. Click here to see a picture of her car.
To this day, that scene remains one of the most unsettling and unexplainable pieces of a case that’s still missing its center: Where is Brianna? What happened that night? And who left the car like that?
The Rumors
As soon as Brianna vanished, rumors exploded. That she was mixed up in drugs. That she owed someone money. That she’d been abducted by someone she knew. That she’d been murdered and her body dumped on a pig farm. That she’d been trafficked. That she'd staged her own disappearance.
But here’s the thing: none of those rumors have ever been confirmed. Not by law enforcement. Not by evidence. And not by the people who knew her best.
What We Know (and What We Don’t)
Brianna was last seen leaving work around 11:20 PM.
Her car was found less than two miles away—abandoned in a way no one could explain.
Her belongings were left behind, including contact lenses, medication, and clothes.
Her mom didn’t find out she was missing until five days later.
The barn where the car was found had no usable surveillance, no witnesses, and the car wasn’t even reported suspicious by police until later.
There were suspects. There were confessions. There were “friends” who changed their stories. But still—no arrests. No confirmed sightings. No Brianna.
Why This Case Still Haunts
The case of Brianna Maitland is frustrating not just because it’s unsolved, but because the clues feel like they should’ve led somewhere. The car. The scene. The people she knew. There’s something in that story that doesn’t add up, and we think it’s time to stop pretending it does.
In this week’s episode of Crime Clueless, we break down the evidence, the suspects, the weirdest twists, and why the barn scene still feels like someone was trying to say something—or hide something. Because Brianna didn’t leave that way. She didn’t stage that scene. And someone out there knows the truth.
🧩 She Didn’t Leave That Way—She Deserves Answers
Brianna Maitland didn’t vanish on her own. She didn’t abandon her life, her friends, or her future. Something happened that night on a dark Vermont road—and the scene she left behind has never made sense.
If you want to learn more, get involved, or just refuse to forget, here are trusted resources to explore the case further:
🔗 Resources at a Glance:
Seven Days Vermont: Brianna’s Disappearance
The Vanished Podcast – Ep 27
Vermont State Police – Case Listing
Charley Project: Brianna’s Timeline
If you have any information about Brianna Maitland’s disappearance, no matter how small, please contact the Vermont State Police at (802) 524-5993 or the FBI at (800) CALL-FBI.
🎧 Listen Now:
One Night in Vermont: The Vanishing of Brianna Maitland
Streaming wherever you get your podcasts. Bring your theories—and your side-eye. Share it, talk about it, and don’t let this case stay cold.
Have thoughts on this story or other cases you’d like to see highlighted? Share them with us in the comments or connect with us on social media. Together, we can ensure that stories like this one are never forgotten.
Don’t forget to follow us on social media, share your thoughts, and let us know what you’d like to hear about in future episodes. If you have any true crime stories of your own, send them our way crimeclueless@gmail.com to be featured on a future episode! And as always, remember: refuse to be clueless, careless, or caught off guard. Not today, murderers.
See you in the next episode of Crime Clueless!
🗂️ Brianna Maitland Case – Research & Resources
📰 News Articles & Case Coverage
Seven Days Vermont – “The Long Road: Searching for Brianna Maitland”
One of the most thorough and emotionally resonant articles on Brianna’s case. Includes interviews, history, and updated leads.NBC News – “The Mysterious Disappearance of Brianna Maitland”
Great overview from a national spotlight series on cold cases.The Charley Project – Brianna Maitland Case File
The most detailed timeline and documentation of the known facts surrounding her disappearance.Vermont State Police Cold Case Listing
Official case status and statement from investigators.
🎧 Podcasts & Audio Coverage
The Vanished Podcast – Episode 27: Brianna Maitland
A deeply researched, emotionally grounded look at Brianna’s life and disappearance.Crime Junkie – MISSING: Brianna Maitland
A clear, accessible narrative of the case with focus on key details.Unresolved Podcast – Brianna Maitland
Explores different theories and possible suspects with more emphasis on analysis.
📚 Community Forums, Documents & Analysis
Websleuths: Brianna Maitland Discussion Thread
Long-running forum where amateur sleuths analyze timelines, suspects, and police response.Reddit – r/UnresolvedMysteries: Brianna Maitland Mega-Thread
Deep-dive discussions and theories, plus links to court documents and FOIA’d files.Justice for Brianna Facebook Page
Run by her family and advocates—shares updates, media coverage, and case awareness campaigns.
📢 Cold Case & Victim Support Resources
National Center for Missing & Exploited Children – Brianna’s Poster
Official missing poster and vital stats still in circulation.Private Investigations for the Missing (Bruce Maitland’s Organization)
Founded by Brianna’s father to help other families searching for answers.
Comments
Post a Comment